Skip to content
MONTEGRE

EU Court Orders Banks to Refund Online Fraud Victims Within One Day

European Court of Justice rules banks must immediately reimburse unauthorized transactions even if the customer was negligent.

Sources: Il Fatto Quotidiano, Valencia Plaza, Alicante Plaza3 sources ↓|· 1 min read

KEY POINTS

  • European Court of Justice ruled on October 15, 2026, in case C-70/25
  • Banks must refund unauthorized transactions by the end of the next business day
  • Customer negligence cannot be used to deny or delay refunds
  • Responsibility for losses is determined only after the money is returned
  • The only exception is proven suspicion that the account holder committed the fraud

The European Court of Justice issued a landmark ruling on October 15, 2026, in case C-70/25 regarding online banking fraud and money theft. The decision directly affects the application of the European Union's payment services directive, which was incorporated into Italian law through Legislative Decree 11 of 2010.

Previously, many intermediaries denied or indefinitely froze refunds, blaming the saver for entering codes or opening fraudulent links. The court clarified that customer protection cannot be subordinated to a presumption of guilt, meaning users retain the right to immediate re-crediting of stolen funds even if they were deceived.

“The court clarified that customer protection cannot be subordinated to a presumption of guilt.”

— European Court of Justice

The ruling establishes a two-stage procedural mechanism separating the obligation to refund from the subsequent assignment of responsibility. As soon as a customer formally disputes an unauthorized transaction, the bank must re-credit the exact amount withdrawn by the end of the next business day following notification.

Banks cannot use procedural loopholes, conduct lengthy preliminary checks, or demand technical expert reports to release liquidity. The only exception to this immediate restoration occurs when there is a founded and proven suspicion that the account holder devised or carried out the fraud.

The case originated from a Polish woman attempting to sell an item online. A supposed buyer sent her a fraudulent link simulating her bank's website, allowing scammers to obtain her credentials and make payment operations. The conflict reached European justice after the bank's obligation to refund money was questioned amid indications of possible serious negligence by the client.

The resolution interprets the European payment services directive, incorporated into Spanish legislation through Royal Decree-Law 19/2018. Article 45 establishes that when an unauthorized operation occurs, financial institutions cannot delay or reject the refund based on arguments that the client acted with serious negligence.

COMMENTS (0)

0/2000

No comments yet. Be the first.

RELATED STORIES

This page was compiled with AI assistance from the outlets named above and passed an automated language check before publication. Montegre has no reporters of its own; the byline names the outlets the story was compiled from. Method and editorial standards