Court Sentences Eight in Malatya Hotel Collapse Case, Acquits Three
Eight defendants received prison terms ranging from eight years four months to fourteen years two months, while three were acquitted in the Kırçuval Hotel trial.
KEY POINTS
- Twenty-one people died and three were injured when the Kırçuval Hotel collapsed in the 6 February 2023 earthquakes.
- Eight defendants were convicted and three were acquitted at the twelfth hearing.
- Prison sentences ranged from eight years four months to fourteen years two months.
- The court rejected detention requests and continued judicial control measures.
- Victims’ relatives said they would continue their struggle for justice and appeal to a higher court.
A court in Malatya has announced its verdict in the trial over the collapse of the Kırçuval Hotel during the 6 February 2023 earthquakes. Twenty-one people died under the rubble, including six volleyball players from Malatya Büyükşehir Belediyespor and four amputee footballers. Three other people were injured in the incident.
The Malatya 5th Heavy Penal Court delivered the ruling at the twelfth hearing of the case. Eight defendants were convicted, while Aziz Murat Palancı, Fırat Palancı and İsmail Y. were acquitted. The court rejected requests to detain those sentenced and ruled that existing judicial control measures would continue.
“We want the defendants to receive the heaviest penalty and for justice to be served.”
Prison terms ranged from eight years four months to fourteen years two months. Saffet Kırçuval and Zafer Kırçuval each received eight years four months. Fatma Altaş was sentenced to twelve years two months twenty days and banned from her profession for six years three months. Hayriye Doğan received fourteen years two months and a seven-year seven-month professional ban.
Relatives of the victims criticized the sentences and the decision not to detain the convicted defendants outside the courthouse. Their lawyer said objections to the acquittals, the legal classification of the offense and the rejected detention requests would be taken to a higher court.
The investigation examined the hotel’s construction, planning, licensing, renovation and operation. The Malatya Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office had prepared an indictment against eleven people for causing the death and injury of more than one person through conscious negligence.
The seven-storey hotel in Dabakhane neighborhood collapsed during the first earthquake on 6 February 2023. Four people were rescued from the rubble according to one account, while another said three were injured. The hotel had hosted athletes, including members of Malatya Büyükşehir Belediyespor’s volleyball team and amputee footballers.
3 more sources below
COMMENTS (0)
No comments yet. Be the first.
RELATED STORIES

Family of woman who died during C-section says organs were removed; IMSS says they are preserved
The family of Sofía Calderón alleges her body was delivered without several organs after a C-section in Monterrey; IMSS says the organs were kept for autopsy analysis.

Texas execution lasted over an hour amid vein difficulties
Reinaldo Dennes was executed in Huntsville after staff struggled to insert intravenous needles for more than an hour.

Mother of Five Dies After Brazilian Butt Lift at Friend's Home
Alice Webb, 33, died following a BBL procedure performed by Jordan Parke in Gloucester in September 2024.
- Daily pill eradicates advanced pancreatic cancer in some patients
- Eight-Day Search Continues for Missing 80-Year-Old in Kocaeli
- Denizli Ponzi Scheme Mastermind Sentenced to 74 Years in Prison
- Russian missile strike hits Kyiv bridges as Polish provinces go on alert
- Fiona the Hippo Receives Round-the-Clock Care After Swallowing Visitor's Hat at Cincinnati Zoo
This page was compiled with AI assistance from the outlets named above and passed an automated language check before publication. Montegre has no reporters of its own; the byline names the outlets the story was compiled from. Method and editorial standards