Skip to content
MONTEGRE

B.C. judge dismisses defamation suit over residential school book dispute

A B.C. Supreme Court judge ruled that a Quesnel councillor’s comments about a book on residential schools were protected speech.

Sources: Quesnel Cariboo Observer, Vernon Morning Star, Nelson Star, Trail Times and 4 more8 sources ↓|· 1 min read

KEY POINTS

  • B.C. Supreme Court Justice Tindale dismissed the defamation lawsuit on November 10.
  • Pat Morton, wife of former Quesnel Mayor Ron Paull, sued Councillor Laurey-Anne Roodenburg.
  • The dispute concerned Morton’s distribution of a book questioning residential school findings.
  • Roodenburg’s March 19, 2024, comments were ruled protected under the Protection of Public Participation Act.
  • The Lhtako Dene Nation had written to council expressing concern about the book’s content.

A B.C. Supreme Court judge has dismissed a defamation lawsuit filed by Pat Morton, the wife of former Quesnel Mayor Ron Paull. The suit targeted Quesnel Councillor Laurey-Anne Roodenburg over comments made during a March 19, 2024, council meeting.

Justice Tindale published the decision on November 10, ruling that Roodenburg’s statements were protected under the Protection of Public Participation Act. The controversy began after Morton distributed copies of a book titled Grave Error: How the Media Misled Us (and the Truth about Residential Schools).

“I respect the fact that people have the right to their own opinions, but what I don't see here is the respect that your wife has shown you in your role as mayor of this community.”

— Laurey-Anne Roodenburg

Morton had purchased the book in February 2024. On March 19, 2024, the Lhtako Dene Nation sent a letter to the mayor and council expressing concern that the book questioned the existence of residential schools and whether cultural genocide had occurred.

During the meeting, Paull identified his wife as the person distributing the book and said he had not read it. Roodenburg, who served as the city’s Indigenous Liaison at the time, criticized Morton’s actions, saying they showed a lack of respect for the mayor’s position and harmed First Nations communities.

Roodenburg told the meeting that people have the right to their own opinions but that the situation was causing serious harm to First Nations communities, including Lhtako and surrounding areas. She also described the distribution as disrespectful to the mayor’s role.

The court’s dismissal ends the legal action brought by Morton against Roodenburg. No further details about potential appeals or costs were included in the published decision.

COMMENTS (0)

0/2000

No comments yet. Be the first.

RELATED STORIES

This page was compiled with AI assistance from the outlets named above and passed an automated language check before publication. Montegre has no reporters of its own; the byline names the outlets the story was compiled from. Method and editorial standards