UK tribunal orders disclosure of secret Apple data access demand
A London tribunal has ruled the British government must publicly acknowledge its secret order to Apple for access to encrypted user data.

KEY POINTS
- London tribunal rules UK government must disclose secret Apple data access order
- Order issued under Investigatory Powers Act as a technical capability notice
- Tribunal rejects government claim that disclosure would harm national security
- Apple refused the demand and removed Advanced Data Protection from the UK market
- Order caused diplomatic tensions with Washington over access to Americans' data
A London tribunal has ruled that the British government must publicly acknowledge its secret demand for access to Apple users' encrypted data. The government lost its legal battle to keep the controversial surveillance order hidden from the public.
The secret order, known as a technical capability notice, was issued under Britain's Investigatory Powers Act. This law gives intelligence and law enforcement agencies broad surveillance powers while banning technology companies from revealing they received such orders.
“Decisions affecting the safety of the British public must be made by democratically elected governments and independent judges, not in the boardrooms of technology companies.”
The tribunal found the government failed to prove that public acknowledgment would harm national security. It rejected Home Office claims that disclosure could assist hostile actors.
The confrontation dates back to January 2025, when London reportedly demanded Apple create a backdoor for British authorities to access encrypted iCloud backups worldwide, including those of American citizens.
Apple refused to comply and withdrew its Advanced Data Protection feature from the British market. The company also challenged the demand in court, warning that weakening encryption would undermine customer privacy and security.
The original order sparked a diplomatic row with Washington. US officials and lawmakers raised concerns that British intelligence could access Americans' private information. London reportedly withdrew the worldwide demand following negotiations with the administration of US President Donald Trump.
2 more sources below
COMMENTS (0)
No comments yet. Be the first.
RELATED STORIES

Estonia to close Russia border crossings from December 1 over sabotage
Estonia will shut all land crossings with Russia starting 1 December after a suspected arson attack on a drone manufacturer, citing Russian sabotage.

Romania offers tax cuts and funds for voluntary municipal mergers
The government proposes halving local property taxes for five years and granting at least four million lei to each merging locality.

Skydance completes Warner Bros Discovery purchase and removes DC Studios leaders Gunn and Safran
Jeremy Latcham takes over DC Studios as Man of Tomorrow remains in post-production amid unconfirmed Paramount+ merger talk.
- Signal Blocks Screenshots to Stop AI Agents Reading Private Chats
- Malaysia to Resettle 10,000 Rohingya Refugees in Turkey
- Meta's Muse AI Agent Raises Privacy Concerns After Unsolicited Messages and Data Access
- US chip curbs hit Chinese AI firms as TSMC tightens orders
- Rockstar Reveals GTA 6 Lead Actors After Years of Secrecy
This page was compiled with AI assistance from the outlets named above and passed an automated language check before publication. Montegre has no reporters of its own; the byline names the outlets the story was compiled from. Method and editorial standards