Skip to content
MONTEGRE

Brazil Supreme Court to Decide Whether Senator-Elect Van Hattem Faces Slander Trial

The First Chamber will judge virtually whether to accept the prosecutor's complaint against the lawmaker over remarks made in August 2024.

Sources: Valor Econômico, Metrópoles, Brasil 247, Diário do Centro do Mundo and 1 more5 sources ↓|· 2 min read
Brazil Supreme Court to Decide Whether Senator-Elect Van Hattem Faces Slander Trial
Photo: Valor Econômico

KEY POINTS

  • Supreme Court First Chamber will judge Van Hattem virtually from November 20 to 30
  • He is accused of slander and insult against Federal Police delegate Fabio Alvarez Shor
  • The accusations relate to an August 2024 speech in the Chamber of Deputies
  • Filipe Martins was sentenced to 21 years in December 2025 for an attempted coup
  • The Brazilian Bar Association wants the case moved to a physical session

The First Chamber of Brazil's Supreme Federal Court will decide in a virtual session running from November 20 to 30 whether to accept a complaint against federal deputy and senator-elect Marcel van Hattem. He is accused of slander and insult against Federal Police delegate Fabio Alvarez Shor. The case stems from a speech Van Hattem delivered in the Chamber of Deputies in August 2024.

During that speech, Van Hattem accused Shor of abuse of authority and producing fraudulent reports in investigations involving Filipe Martins, a former international affairs adviser to ex-president Jair Bolsonaro. He displayed a photograph of the officer and called him an "abuser of authority of the Federal Police." Van Hattem also said Shor had acted "like a criminal" and questioned his role in the investigation that led to Martins's arrest.

“In a jurisdictional system based on orality, the opportunity for oral argument allows the lawyer to highlight specific points of evidence and clarify the judges' doubts.”

— Brazilian Bar Association

The lawmaker argued that Martins's name appeared only in preliminary versions of a file and was removed from later versions. He also said cellphone location records showed Martins was in Brazil during the relevant period. Based on these arguments, Van Hattem accused Shor of incompetence and irresponsibility in requesting the arrest.

Martins was convicted in December 2025 by the First Chamber to 21 years in prison for participating in an attempted coup. The ruling said he presented Bolsonaro with a draft containing exceptional measures to keep him in power, including the arrest of Justice Alexandre de Moraes and the calling of new elections.

The Brazilian Bar Association asked Justice Flavio Dino to reconsider his decision and have Van Hattem judged in a physical plenary session. The association requested permission to join the inquiry as an assistant to defend lawyers' prerogatives and stressed that its intervention is purely institutional, focused on oral argument rights rather than Van Hattem's legal or political defense.

Dino rejected the defense's earlier request for in-person oral arguments. The Bar Association said that in a system based on orality, oral argument allows lawyers to highlight specific evidence and clarify judges' doubts, which is replaced in a virtual asynchronous setting by decontextualized recordings limited to a monologue without interaction.

COMMENTS (0)

0/2000

No comments yet. Be the first.

RELATED STORIES

This page was compiled with AI assistance from the outlets named above and passed an automated language check before publication. Montegre has no reporters of its own; the byline names the outlets the story was compiled from. Method and editorial standards