Argentina's Supreme Court Blocks Private Health Insurer Fee Hikes, Decrees Unconstitutional
The court struck down two articles of President Milei's decree and restored state control over private health plan price increases.
KEY POINTS
- Supreme Court declared articles 267 and 269 of decree 70/2023 unconstitutional
- Private health insurers must now obtain state authorization for fee increases
- The case originated from a 110 percent hike by Swiss Medical between December 2023 and February 2024
- Justices Rosatti, Rosenkrantz, and Lorenzetti signed the ruling
- Nearly 500 similar cases await resolution and may be affected by the decision
Argentina's Supreme Court declared two articles of President Javier Milei's decree 70/2023 unconstitutional, ending free price increases by private health insurance companies. The ruling requires companies to submit their fee hikes to the Health Services Superintendency for authorization and oversight.
The decision came from a case involving Swiss Medical, where a member faced a 110 percent fee increase between December 2023 and February 2024. Under the previous regulatory scheme, the authorized increase for January 2024 would have been only 6.26 percent.
“The ruling represents a setback for one of the central aspects of the government's economic deregulation policy.”
Justices Horacio Rosatti, Carlos Rosenkrantz, and Ricardo Lorenzetti signed the ruling, marking the court's first declaration of unconstitutionality regarding the mega decree promoted by the executive branch. The case reached the court after both the private health company and the national state filed extraordinary appeals.
The court specifically annulled articles 267 and 269 of the decree, which had modified Law 26.682 regulating private medicine and eliminated state intervention powers over sector prices. The Superintendency must now review tariff modifications, control their reasonableness, and authorize increases justified by cost structure variations and actuarial risk calculations.
The ruling has direct implications for nearly 500 similar cases still awaiting resolution in the court itself. It could also guide numerous legal protections filed by members in federal courts across the country, including claims seeking reimbursement for excess payments.
The court did not establish an automatic limit linked to inflation and nullified part of a previous sentence that had capped increases at consumer price index variation. Companies may request tariff updates but must justify them properly.
2 more sources below
COMMENTS (0)
No comments yet. Be the first.
RELATED STORIES

Brazil's Supreme Court to Rule on Sentencing Law That May Reduce Bolsonaro's Term
STF will judge four challenges to the Dosimetry Law between December 4 and 15, with possible effects on Bolsonaro's 27-year sentence.

Dollar Surpasses R$5.84 Amid Fiscal Package Uncertainty in Brazil
The Brazilian real weakened against the dollar as investors reacted to doubts over the government's fiscal adjustment plan and higher U.S. interest rates.

Sánchez prepares for televised debate against Feijóo amid 2023 trauma
Spain's prime minister rehearses for tonight's head-to-head with opposition leader Alberto Núñez Feijóo at the Television Academy.
- APC Leaders Urge Igbo Support for Tinubu’s 2027 Re-election in Anambra Rally
- Florida to carry out 20th execution of the year Thursday
- Security Offensive Falls Short of Territorial Control After 100 Days
- Argentina's country risk climbs above 930 points as dollar hits yearly high
- University rector survives Konya car crash, wife dies
This page was compiled with AI assistance from the outlets named above and passed an automated language check before publication. Montegre has no reporters of its own; the byline names the outlets the story was compiled from. Method and editorial standards