Skip to content
MONTEGRE

Political dispute leaves two seats vacant on Argentina's Magistrate Council

A standoff between ruling allies in Congress has delayed final appointments to the body that appoints and removes judges.

Sources: Clarín, Perfil, La Nación, TN4 sources ↓|· 2 min read
Political dispute leaves two seats vacant on Argentina's Magistrate Council
Photo: Clarín

KEY POINTS

  • Two councilor seats remain unofficial after terms expired on November 19, 2026
  • Senate appointments were finalized on Tuesday, November 18, 2026
  • United Provinces bloc demands a second-minority seat claimed by PRO
  • Martin Menem has not submitted proposed names to the Supreme Court
  • No legal deadline exists for appointing new councilors

The new Council of the Magistracy was supposed to be fully formed on Wednesday, November 19, 2026, when the terms of the previous councilors expired. However, its definitive integration remains incomplete because of a political dispute in Congress and differences among academics that will be settled in court. Two seats remain unofficial: one representative from the Chamber of Deputies and one academic member.

In the Senate, negotiations concluded on Tuesday. Vice President Victoria Villarruel signed a decree recognizing the Peronist bloc as the majority and officially naming Buenos Aires representative Eduardo "Wado" De Pedro and La Rioja representative Florencia Lopez as councilors, with San Juan's Sergio Uñac as alternate. The Radical Civic Union retained the second-minority seat, held by Maximiliano Abad, while outgoing Corrientes representative Eduardo Vischi became the alternate.

“The new Council of the Magistracy was supposed to be fully formed today, but its definitive integration depends on a political dispute in Congress and differences among academics that will be resolved in the courts.”

— La Nación

The Senate dispute began in late October when La Rioja lawmaker Fernando Rejal returned to the Justicialist bloc led by Jose Mayans, giving Peronism 22 senators, one more than the bloc led by Patricia Bullrich. A report from the Senate Parliamentary Secretariat and a legal consultation by La Libertad Avanza convinced the libertarians to drop their resistance.

In the Chamber of Deputies, the equation reversed. La Libertad Avanza will hold two councilor seats as the majority bloc: Gonzalo Roca, already a councilor, and Giselle Castelnuovo, both linked to Martin and Eduardo "Lule" Menem. Union for the Homeland drops from two councilors to one, with Cristina Kirchner blessing the nomination of federal Peronist deputy Guillermo Michel, close to Sergio Massa. Rodolfo Tailhade and Vanesa Siley, two kirchnerist leaders, are leaving.

The conflict centers on a second-minority seat claimed by the United Provinces bloc, controlled by governors Maximiliano Pullaro, Martin Llaryora, and Ignacio "Nacho" Torres. The bloc caused Wednesday's session to fail by demanding the seat, which the ruling coalition had assigned to Cristian Ritondo's PRO. Ritondo had proposed Buenos Aires deputy Florencia de Sensi after Alvaro Gonzalez withdrew following a Supreme Court message rejecting reelections.

Martin Menem has not yet sent the proposed names to the Supreme Court, and the ruling coalition has tried to downplay the issue despite the expiration of current congressional representatives' terms. There is no deadline for appointing new councilors, and the body has previously functioned without all members. The last precedent was in 2022, when Peronism sought both majority seats and one second-minority seat, leading Luis Juez to file a court claim for the PRO seat.

COMMENTS (0)

0/2000

No comments yet. Be the first.

RELATED STORIES

This page was compiled with AI assistance from the outlets named above and passed an automated language check before publication. Montegre has no reporters of its own; the byline names the outlets the story was compiled from. Method and editorial standards